RIGHT
flag post
is your sis hot?
Posted By: lu ee
Explain My Vote
If she needs to get around i'll take her off your hands. And yeah pay her back and the car is all yours again, moron!
|
WRONG
flag post
Do the right thing
Posted By: not your sister
Explain My Vote
if she is still paying for the car costs then she should be able to let your brother use it once in a while, if he starts to use it all the time then he should be paying the costs that she does.
|
WRONG
flag post
Do the right thing
Posted By: not your sister
Explain My Vote
if she is still paying for the car costs then she should be able to let your brother use it once in a while, if he starts to use it all the time then he should be paying the costs that she does.
|
RIGHT
flag post
Whose name is the car in?
Posted By: Yeah-right
Explain My Vote
That was one detail not stated.
Suppose your brother decides that he, in turn can lend the car to yet another party - and they either wreck it, or engage in behavior that gets it seized?
The agreement was for you and your sister to alternate. It didn't provide for a third party. If she is loaning it out to someone else, she is in violation of the agreement. This is like a partnership, where one party can get the other into financial (and even legal) difficulty without their knowledge of consent.
Either re-state the agreement in writing this time, or dissolve the agreement and one buys out the other, or sell it and split the proceeds.
|
WRONG
flag post
Wrong
Posted By: WastedWit
Explain My Vote
If theres one thing I do know....it's everything!
This is a no win situation. Actually since it's her weekend
she could lock it up and let it sit.
Trust she'll do the right thing(she is your sister after all)
give her the keys man...just give her the keys!!!
|
RIGHT
flag post
buy her out
Posted By: LB
Explain My Vote
The biggest issue is the liability. You two can drive the car, but no one else should. It would make for a legal nightmare if someone else, who is not a legal owner, gets in an accident. You could be held responsible too even if it was your sister's "weekend". If she doesn't need the car anymore, buy her out, end the headache and preserve your relationship with your sister.
|
WRONG
flag post
wrong
Posted By: Lily
Explain My Vote
She's paying half so she deserves to be able to do whatever she wants with the car on her weekends. Why would you be entitled to use the car on her weekends?
|
WRONG
flag post
Can't We All Just Get Along?
Posted By: Henrietta
Explain My Vote
Do you really want to spend your life micro managing your sister? Trust me, that will be completely exhausting and will have little effect. Your sister's weekends are her weekends and you are not going to be there to see who is driving and who is not. Make sure she knows that her weekends are her responsibilty and even sign something legal to the effect that she is financially responsible to fix the car if you are worried about it, but then trust her and that she will make wise decisions because it is her transprotation too. Remember though: accidents do happen and they could happen to you too. Buckle up.
|
RIGHT
flag post
Nope sorry
Posted By: Sally
Explain My Vote
You should always get the car when she is not using it.
|
RIGHT
flag post
Nope sorry
Posted By: Sally
Explain My Vote
You should always get the car when she is not using it.
|
WRONG
flag post
Nope
Posted By: Jessie
Explain My Vote
If your sister is paying for half she should be able to do what ever she wants. End of story
|
RIGHT
flag post
No way
Posted By: Mark
Explain My Vote
You are way right on this one.
|
RIGHT
flag post
Should not have to share
Posted By: No
Explain My Vote
I do not think you should have to share. Tell her its all or nothing.
|
